Insights

Partnership Litigation: Can You Sue Your Business Partner?

King and Jones Chicago business litigation legal services illustration
By:

Yes, in many situations one business partner can sue another. A lawsuit usually follows a dispute the partners could not resolve, such as a partner who breaks the partnership agreement, breaches a fiduciary duty, or acts negligently. If you are weighing that step, a Chicago partnership dispute lawyer can explain your options before you file.

What Is A Partnership Dispute Or Lawsuit?

A partnership dispute concerns the owners of a business. If you cannot resolve the dispute in an acceptable manner, then one owner may make a legal claim against the other owner or owners, called partnership dispute litigation. Business partnership litigation cases are never enjoyable, and often, typically no one wants matters to escalate to a trial. However, if your business partner is acting in an unreasonable or illegal manner, a partnership lawsuit may be your best option. Sometimes litigation is necessary to prevent illegal activity from tarnishing your role in the business.

Few people expect that they will need to resort to a partnership dispute lawsuit. However, this is precisely why every company needs a business litigation lawyer.

Why Partner Disputes Start

Disagreements About Business Operations

Although business partners are generally on the same page when they’re just starting out, disagreements sometimes arise among partners as the business evolves. Common partnership disputes include:

  • What percentage of the profits should be reinvested
  • How to manage employees
  • What tasks to outsource and what tasks should be performed by in-house personnel
  • What constitutes acceptable risk when it comes to business expansion strategies

It’s also common for partners to develop differing big-picture visions over the course of time, which may affect anything from decisions on branding to overall company direction.

A comprehensive partnership agreement will have addressed the possibility of these issues arising at some future point and will provide guidelines for navigating closely held business disputes. It’s common, however, for the initial agreement to be incomplete or for the individual parties to have different interpretations of the main points of the agreement, potentially necessitating the involvement of a partnership dispute lawyer in the future.

Money problems can also erode trust. Our post on business partner fraud gives examples of fraud between partners.

Duties Business Partners Owe Each Other

Those engaged in business partnerships have fiduciary duties both to one another as well as to the business. Our post on what a breach of fiduciary duty is explains more.

The fiduciary relationship requires trust, and the law recognizes the unique relationship and aims to protect it. A fiduciary will have a heightened burden of proof if he or she engages in transactions involving the beneficiary or subservient party.

For example, in Labovitz, a case in which we represented the plaintiff limited partners, the general partner of a cable TV limited partnership withheld cash distributions to the limited partners while they incurred significant tax obligations. The general partner then offered to buy out the limited partners at a bargain price. The trial court dismissed the complaint , which alleged a coerced buyout, by relying on the broad discretion the partnership agreement granted the general partner. The appellate court reversed that decision, holding that the language of the partnership agreement did not trump the general partner’s fiduciary duties. The court cited an opinion by Judge Cardozo and quoted: “copartners, owe to one another …the duty of finest loyalty…..A trustee is held to something stricter that the morals of the market place.” The Court went on to state that in a fiduciary relationship the burden shifts to the fiduciary to show by clear and convincing evidence that the transaction is equitable and just.

Every case is unique, and results may vary.

This is the high standard that Courts hold fiduciaries. So, after a plaintiff (beneficiary of the fiduciary) establishes that a fiduciary engaged in self-dealing, the burden shifts to the fiduciary. He or she must then prove the transaction’s fairness by a heightened burden of proof.

Common Grounds for Suing a Partner

There are plenty of situations that can lead to business partnership litigation. Partner lawsuits most often grow out of situations like these:

Abandonment

Abandonment becomes an issue when the actions of one business partner mean they effectively left the partnership without proper dissolution of the business. Depending on the terms of your company agreement, you may be entitled to legal action to protect your rights.

Breach Of Fiduciary Duty

You and the other business owners have specific fiduciary duties, and each has legal obligations to uphold these duties as outlined in your company’s contracts. Some examples of fiduciary duty violations include:

  • Charging personal expenses to the company
  • Competing with the partnership
  • Disproportionate profit distribution
  • Acting with gross negligence and recklessness

If you think a partner is taking money from the business, read our post on what to do when a partner steals.

Negligence

If your partner has acted negligently, you may be able to sue them. In these cases, you must generally be able to show that your partner acted unreasonably under the circumstances and that your business suffered harm due to these actions.

Partnership Contract Violations

Contract violations are another situation that can lead to business partnership litigation. Partnership agreements are legally binding documents. A breach of contract can open the business up to unscrupulous behavior. These contracts often define important legal issues within the company, like:

  • Distribution of profits
  • Liability
  • Partner responsibilities

Two frequently breached terms are:

  • Nondisclosure agreements: These prohibit the disclosure of confidential information gleaned in the process of engaging in business transactions.
  • Noncompete agreements: These delineate specific prohibitions regarding parties’ formation of a competing business.

Partnership agreements are often not legally required to start a business, but having one can help your business run smoothly.

Being Forced Out

If someone is wrongfully trying to force you out of the partnership, you can file a lawsuit against the partner personally or the partnership.

Alternatives to a Lawsuit

Of course, partnership disputes do not always need to escalate to the courtroom. You can use many processes to resolve disputes. Some processes may even be written into your business’s legal papers, such as operating agreements. Some standard processes to resolve disputes include types of alternative dispute resolution (ADR), like:

  • Mediation
  • Arbitration
  • Negotiation

It is sometimes advisable to try to resolve issues via ADR first. However, in some situations, business partnership litigation may be your first option.

A mediator is a trained professional who helps facilitate discussions between the two parties. You may even take your case to arbitration if the partnership agreement requires it or the two partners agree to use that method to resolve the dispute.

Partners can also settle a dispute by changing how the partnership works:

  • One partner can purchase the other’s share of the business.
  • You can amend the partnership agreement to resolve the dispute and change the terms of the relationship between the partners.

If the goal is to end the partnership, our guide to ending a business partnership may help.

When Litigation Is the Right Call

Litigation may be the right call when out-of-court efforts have failed. Signs of failure can include a partner who will not respond or negotiate, talks that go nowhere again and again, agreements that are ignored after they are signed, and conduct that continues or gets worse while you try to work it out.

What Steps Should You Take When Undergoing A Business Divorce?

When undergoing a business partnership dissolution, there are specific steps you should take. These steps can help you protect your business and your interests. A lawyer who handles business disputes can guide you through each step below.

Define Your Business Goals And Ideal Outcome

You should define your business goals and articulate your ideal outcome. If your expectations are unrealistic, this can lead to a necessary conversation with your lawyer to help you set realistic goals and expectations. Sometimes business owners expect much more than they are entitled to.

Develop A Solid Business Litigation Game Plan

A solid business litigation game plan can help ensure you have all your bases covered and that all potential legal avenues have been explored. Once you understand the various legal options, you will be more empowered to choose the legal route that best serves your business goals. This should be the route that is most likely to lead to your ideal outcome. An experienced business litigation attorney will ensure you understand all the available options, that your plan is solid, and your expectations align with reality.

Understand And Plan For The Cost Of Business Litigation

The final step is understanding the cost of business litigation and accurately budgeting for it. Business litigation is not cheap, but sometimes it is necessary. Different legal options will carry differing price tags. If cost is a significant concern, exploring the various alternative dispute resolution methods may make sense before pursuing litigation. In other cases, quick litigation resolution may be the most value-conscious choice.

Talk With a Business Lawyer

Whether you can sue your business partner depends on your agreement, your role in the business, and what your partner did. A lawyer can review your agreement and records, explain which claims may apply, and help you compare a lawsuit with the other options in this post.

If a lawsuit feels premature, read our guide to removing a business partner in court first.

Talk With King & Jones

If you are facing a business dispute or a problem with a lawyer’s work, our Chicago trial lawyers can review your situation and explain your options.

You Might Also Like

Ready to discuss your matter? 312-372-4142